The criteria I asked people was to use when evaluating the cards was, How good is the card now and how good is it likely be in the future? I specifically told each person So, you dont need to give Morphling high marks for being awesome ten years ago. There were no set parameters on what constituted a ten or a one on the list rather, the subjects were asked to rate cards in relation to one another, and were largely left to their own devices to figure out how they wanted to score cards
Paying 5 mana and 1 life for a 1/1 weenie just ain't it
Finally, a hard plastic top loader that can hold a sleeved or even double-sleeved card is optimal when mailing cards or protecting cards of value
When you play the same people, with the same collections, using the same style and decks, the game wares out its welcome very quickly
As long as you have Gale on the battlefield and cast an instant or sorcery, you can then cast whichever nonpermanent card type you didn't already cast from your graveyard